Skip to content

Is school the problem?

Bryan Caplan provides comprehensive evidence to show that schools (actually formal education more broadly) is very effective at signalling that individuals are compliant (they do what they are told), reasonably academically able, and work reasonably hard.

Photo of The Case Against Education by Bryan Caplan
Figure 1: The Case Against Education by Bryan Caplan

If that is what we want from school then they they are great at their job. However, this highlights that before you can answer the question 'Is school the problem?' you have to agree what the purpose of schooling should be.

The participants in my recent OU inaugural lecture had a variety of different views about what the purpose of schooling should be (see Figure 2). This illustrates one of the challenges for school leaders - that we don't all have a shared understanding of what schooling is for.

Chart showing responses to the question 'What should the purpose of schooling be?
Figure 2: Responses to the question 'what should the purpose of schooling be' at my OU inaugural lecture (n=247)

My vision for schooling (Figure 3) is that it should result in Individual fulfilment and Universal wellbeing (including for rhinos).

The YinYang Vision
Figure 3: The YinYang Vision

Measured against that yardstick schooling is a problem. For example, De Paoli et al (2018) surveyed a nationally representative group of 500 recent high school students in the USA to find out about their views of high school. As illustrated in Figure 4:

  • 37% said they were held back from learning because they were scared of making mistakes (we know that making mistakes is vital to learning)
  • 51% reported being 'stressed out' all or most of the time
  • 44% identified that they were bored all or most of the time
  • 52% didn't think that their school was good at preparing them to succeed after high school
Graphic showing the percentage of respondents who were afraid to make mistake, were stressed out and/or bored in school and who thought that school hadn't prepared them well for success after school
Figure 4: Summary of some of the data from De Paoli et al's 2018 survey

In the UK behaviour management has become a progressively bigger issue in schools, which suggests that there is a problem. This is evidenced (Figure 5) by:

  • the increase in funding in 2019 to develop new sanctions and rewards to 'crack down on bad behaviour in schools' (DfE May 2019)
  • the 34 fold increase in the use of drugs to manage children aged under 16 in the UK who were labelled as having ADHD between 1995 and 2013 (Beau-Lejdstrom et al 2016)
  • the large and growing number of exclusions from schools in 2015 to 2017 (DfE 2018)
Evidence of increasing 'behaviour' issues in schools
Figure 5: Evidence of increasing 'behaviour' issues in schools

As is often the case with issues to do with behaviour, in all of the above instances the assumption seems to be that children are the problem, with little consideration for the possibility that behaviour issues are due to problems inherent in our current school system. Such issues have contributed to a growing number of families home educating their children (House of Commons 2019) and off-rolling by schools (Ofsted 2018) (see Figure 6).

Increase in the level of homeschooling and evidence that not all children are treated equally by schools
Figure 6: Data on homeschooling and off-rolling of pupils

The fact that Ofsted found it unsurprising that all children were not being treated equally by schools is a damning indictment of schooling (in England). It indicates that they expect schools to be inequitable. That is an outrageous position for the inspectorate to hold and adds further weight to the argument that schooling is not fit for purpose.

Indeed, the English school system (like that in many countries) is driven by high stakes testing, which relies on norm-referencing to distribute students' grades. This approach means that around 30% of the school population has to fail in order for the remaining students to be seen to have succeeded.

An education system that is designed with the expectation that nearly a third of its participants will fail is un-educational. Every child should come out of their schooling feeling that they have succeeded and with a thirst for learning. The fact that this is not the case means that schooling today is a major problem.

This blog post summarises part of my OU inaugural lecture, which was delivered at the OU in Milton Keynes on the 25th June 2019.

Download pdf of this post




Download a pdf of this post

2 thoughts on “Is school the problem?

    1. PeterT

      Hmm. I suspect that more people would agree with you if you had written

    2. A school should be an educational institution designed to provide learning spaces and learning
    3. Or

    4. A school is an educational institution designed to provide teaching spaces and teaching
    5. Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *